The Birther Movement - Barack Obama was born in .... per Barack Obama. Hillary Clinton; Sitting on her ass playing checkers inside her mansion Hillary
Clinton talked to many people but in all reality it was just Bill Clinton,
Cheryl Mills and Huma Abedin that were prepared to risk everything for Hillary.
What Weigel found and re-reported was astounding,
details many of us had forgotten or never heard of, including a 2007 bombshell
memo from the Clinton campaign’s chief strategist.
What the left-wing Weigel left out of his reporting
was even more astounding, including a documented confrontation between Clinton
and Obama over the Birther issue, and video of Hillary herself stoking doubt
about Obama’s Christian faith.
Because the Washington Post‘s primary job is to protect Democrats, Weigel’s headline
and conclusion are an objective lie. Despite the fact that what he uncovered (and
chose to not cover) points directly to Ms. Clinton and her campaign, Weigel
concludes she had nothing to do with the Birther movement.
Naturally, Weigel’s own facts support the exact
opposite conclusion.
His research, however, is all that matters.
Defcon 4: Mark Penn’s March 2007 Strategy Memo
Everything began in March of 2007 when Hillary’s
chief strategist, Mark Penn, wrote a now-infamous campaign memo laying out his
overall plan to win the election.
Weigel sums up the Birther elements of Penn’s memo
as a nothingburger; indeed, according to Weigel, the memo actually proves that
the Clinton campaign wanted nothing to do with Birtherism: “But Penn wrote that
as a warning, not a strategy,” Weigel writes.
While most of Weigel’s lies in his defense of
Clinton are of omission and deflection, the wrist-flicking of Penn’s memo is
pure audacity.
Because this is important, I’m not asking anyone to
believe my interpretation of the memo. You can read the memo for yourself here.
Below are two mainstream media sources. [emphasis added] As you’ll see, the
idea that the memo was a warning against “othering” Obama is preposterous:
The Atlantic:
[Penn] wrote, “I cannot imagine America electing a
president during a time of war who is not at his center fundamentally American
in his thinking and in his values.” Penn proposed targeting Obama’s “lack of
American roots.”
Bloomberg
The idea of going after Obama’s otherness dates
back to the last presidential election—and to Democrats. … Hillary Clinton’s
chief strategist, Mark Penn, recognized this potential vulnerability in Obama
and sought to exploit it. … Penn wrote: … “[H]is roots to basic American values
and culture are at best limited. I cannot imagine America electing a president
during a time of war who is not at his center fundamentally American in his
thinking and his values.”
Penn also suggested how the campaign might take
advantage of this. “Every speech should contain the line that you were born in
the middle of America to the middle class in the middle of the last century,”
he advised Clinton. “And talk about the basic bargain as about [sic] the deeply
American values you grew up with, learned as a child, and that drive you
today.” He went on: “Let’s explicitly own ‘American’ in our programs, the
speeches and the values. He doesn’t … Let’s add flag symbols to the backgrounds
[of campaign events].”
Bloomberg adds: “Penn was not a birther.”
His memo didn’t raise the issue of Obama’s
citizenship. Furthermore, he was acutely aware of the political danger that a
Democrat would court by going after Obama in this way, even subliminally: “We
are never going to say anything about his background,” he wrote.
That is what the memo said. The truth, though, is
that the attacks on Obama’s background would come the following year, and those
attacks would not only come from Hillary’s supporters but directly from her own
campaign and her own mouth during a nationally televised 60 Minutes interview.
In March of 2007, the campaign could afford to
attack Obama’s otherness “subliminally.”
By the following year, as the primary losses
mounted, the gloves came completely off.
Defcon 3: Hillary Clinton and Her Supporters Birth
‘Birtherism’
Weigel’s superb reporting uncovered how the Clinton
campaign and legions of diehard Clinton supporters took Penn’s othering
campaign and the questions surrounding Obama’s faith and birthplace to the next
level.
It was no longer subliminal.
By now Clinton’s 2008 presidential aspirations were
in serious jeopardy. Pay special attention to what Weigel writes about John
Heilemann. Weigel’s lie of omission here is crucial and I’ll address it
below: [emphasis added]
According to John Heilemann and Mark Halperin in
Game Change, the most ludicrous “othering” theory that Clinton allies engaged
in was that a tape existed, somewhere, of Michelle Obama denouncing “whitey” —
and that Clinton herself believed it when consigliere Sid Blumenthal talked
about it.
But the Clinton campaign never pursued the idea
that Obama was literally not American, and therefore ineligible for the
presidency. A small group of hardcore Clinton supporters did. Specifically,
anyone reading the fringe Web in the summer of 2008 could find the now-defunct
blog called TexasDarlin, the now-defunct blog PUMAParty, and the
now-conservative blog HillBuzz posting updates on the hunt for a birth
certificate. It was a thin reed, and they knew it.
“It looks like Obama was born in Hawaii, based on a
recently discovered birth announcement found in a Hawaiian newspaper,” one
HillBuzz blogger wrote in July 2008. “It also looks like the reason Obama
refuses to produce his actual birth certificate is that it very likely records
dual Kenyan and U.S. citizenship at
Obama’s birth.”
Weigel’s sleight of hand here is genius. Let’s
unpack the lies of omission.
1. Weigel uses Bloomberg’s John Heilemann as a
witness for the defense of Hillary but intentionally chooses not to tell his
readers that a mere two days earlier, on Monday, Heilemann confirmed on MSNBC’s
Morning Joe that the Birther movement began with the Clinton campaign.
Again, I’m going to quote a left-wing source:
Host Joe Scarborough called Clinton’s attack on
Trump “rich,” saying, “For Hillary Clinton to come out and criticize anybody
for spreading the rumors about Barack Obama, when it all started … with her and
her campaign passing things around in the Democratic primary[.] … This started
with Hillary Clinton, and it was spread by the Clinton team in 2008.” …
Heilemann, author of the insider account of the
2008 election Game Change, said it was the case that Clinton spread the rumors.
“It was the case,” he said. “I’m affirming the Scarborough-Brzezinski assertion.”
2. Weigel also chose not to report:
It was not until April 2008, at the height of the
intensely bitter Democratic presidential primary process, that the touch paper
was properly lit.
An anonymous email circulated by supporters of Mrs.
Clinton, Mr Obama’s main rival for the party’s nomination, thrust a new
allegation into the national spotlight — that he had not been born in Hawaii.
3. Pretending to be naïve, Weigel uses these third
party Democrat attacks on Obama’s identity as proof! that Hillary’s hands are
clean, you know, because it’s her supporters raising the conspiracy, and not
Hillary.
Apparently, it’s only Republicans who are held
accountable for the actions of their supporters.
Apparently, only Republicans are capable of
coordinating with outside groups to do their dirty work.
Despite more smoke than you’ll find in Jeff
Spicoli’s van, Weigel uses that smoke as proof that there is no fire. This
isn’t journalism, it’s desperate partisan spin.
4. Weigel says nothing about the Clinton campaign’s
shattering silence during this smear campaign.
5. Weigel doesn’t want his readers to know that
Barack Obama himself believes Hillary Clinton started the Birther rumors, even
though this fact was reported by no less than Weigel’s own employer at The
Washington Post:
Obama and Clinton were both at Reagan National
Airport on their way to Iowa for a [2007] debate, and the candidates met on the
tarmac for what became a brief but heated conversation. Then-Obama personal
aide Reggie Love witnessed the event and describes it in his new memoir:
[Obama] very respectfully told her the apology was
kind, but largely meaningless, given the emails it was rumored her camp had
been sending out labeling him as a Muslim. Before he could finish his sentence,
she exploded on Obama. In a matter of seconds, she went from composed to
furious. It had not been Obama’s intention to upset her, but he wasn’t going to
play the fool either.
Why Weigel chose to leave all of this crucial
information out is obvious.
Defcon 2: The Clinton Campaign’s
Obama-Is-a-Scary-Muslim Emails
Weigel writes: “In December 2007, a Clinton
campaign worker named Judy Rose sent an e-mail asking whether Obama was a
secret Muslim who intended to destroy America from the inside. She was fired
and denounced.”
Here’s what Weigel doesn’t tell his readers:
The email wasn’t meant for public consumption. It
was an internal email sent to just a handful of Democrats.
Rose was only fired after the media discovered the
email.
Rose wasn’t merely a “Clinton campaign worker,” she
was the volunteer chair of the Clinton campaign in Jones County, Iowa.
A second Clinton staffer resigned just a few days
later for the same offense.
The emails were sent just a little more than a
month before the crucial January of 2008 Iowa Caucus, which Hillary lost.
Defcon 1: The Obama-In-a-Turban Photo
Weigel writes: “Three months later, when the Drudge
Report claimed that a photo of Obama wearing a turban was sent from “stressed
Clinton staffers,” the Clinton campaign denounced it but didn’t find a scalp.”
This is Weigel glossing over one of the most
crucial elements in Hillary’s Birther campaign. Here is the photo in question…
…and Weigel not only buries and downplays this
seismic campaign moment in the middle of a paragraph; laughably, his witness in
defense of Hillary is the Hillary Clinton campaign. Because they couldn’t find
who did it — “a scalp” — we’re asked to conclude that the campaign is innocent.
Here’s what Weigel doesn’t tell his readers:
1. The Obama campaign believes the photo came from
the Clinton campaign.
Another left-wing source:
Obama’s campaign manager, David Plouffe, described
it as “the most shameful, offensive fear-mongering we’ve seen from either party
in this election”. Obama has had to spend much of the campaign stressing he is
a Christian not a Muslim and did not study at a madrassa. …
Plouffe described circulation of the picture as
part of “a disturbing pattern.” “It’s exactly the kind of divisive politics
that turns away Americans of all parties,” he said.
2. Again, Weigel ignores crucial information
published by one of his own employers, in this case his former-employer Slate.
After the Drudge splash, Plouffe released the
statement above condemning the Clinton campaign at 9:29 am. Less than two hours
later, Clinton campaign manager Maggie Williams shot back with a response that,
as Slate notes, “never refuted Drudge’s piece.”
Then, at 10:54 a.m., Clinton’s campaign manager,
Maggie Williams, pierced the quiet with her own release. “Enough,” she wrote.
“If Barack Obama’s campaign wants to suggest that a photo of him wearing
traditional Somali clothing is divisive, they should be ashamed. Hillary Clinton has worn the traditional
clothing of countries she has visited and had those photos published widely.”
She goes on to say Obama is trying to “distract from the serious issues.” Note
that they never refuted Drudge’s piece. (More detail on that piece of the story
is trickling in .)
Let’s take a moment to review: Obama’s campaign
thinks Clinton is trying to be divisive by encouraging the Obama-is-a-Muslim
myth. Clinton’s campaign thinks the Obama campaign is being divisive because it
thinks Clinton’s campaign is being divisive.
The Clinton campaign would eventually deny sending
the photo, but only after it became obvious that the release of the photo was
blowing up in their face.
Mushroom Cloud: Hillary’s “As far as I know,” or
Weigel’s ‘Big Lie’ of Omission
In his attempt to let Hillary off the hook, it is
imperative that Weigel not remind his readers that in March of 2008, in the
middle of her campaign’s Birthernado, and on no less than 60 Minutes, Hillary
herself stoked the Birther rumors.
Obama is not a Muslim “as far as I know,” Clinton
told Steve Kroft.
Hillary Clinton Is Birther Zero
My singling out of Weigel is a bit unfair. But it
was his reporting that put the final details into place. And what he’s
attempting to do is what most of the mainstream media is attempting to do:
protect Hillary from her own racist past with half-truths and the omission of
facts.
Once you do what the mainstream media refuses: put
all the facts together as I did here, only those who don’t believe in science
would let Hillary off the hook.
Here are the facts:
More than a full year before anyone would hear of
Orly Taitz, the Birther strategy was first laid out in the Penn memo.
The “othering” foundation was built subliminally by
the Clinton campaign itself.
Democrats and Clinton campaign surrogates did the
dirtiest of the dirty work: openly spread the Birther lies.
Staffers in Hillary’s actual campaign used email to
spread the lies among other Democrats (this was a Democrat primary after all —
so that is the only well you needed to poison a month before a primary).
The campaign released the turban photo.
Hillary herself used 60 Minutes to further stoke
these lies.
Of course Hillary Clinton is the grandmother of the
Birther Movement. But now that she might be the only thing between a Republican
and the White House, Dave Weigel’s reverting back to JournoList form, as is the
rest of the media.
Hillary Clinton who started the movement.
President Obama’s father was born in Kenya and his
mother was from Kansas. Obama, himself, as born in Honolulu, Hawaii.
Breitbart News confirmed that Clinton began the
birther movement in 2007 and 2008 while she was campaigning against the then
Illinois senator and candidate for president.
Among other pieces of evidence, John Nolte pointed
out that the Wall Street Journal’s David Weigel took an in-depth look at the
origins of the rumors that President Obama is a practicing Muslim who was not
born in America. What Weigel found and re-reported included a 2007 bombshell
memo from the Clinton campaign’s chief strategist, Mark Penn.
Nolte sums up the facts of the Clinton campaign’s
birther rumors as follows:
More than a full year before anyone would hear of
Orly Taitz, the Birther strategy was first laid out in the Penn memo.
The “othering” foundation was built subliminally by
the Clinton campaign itself.
Democrats and Clinton campaign surrogates did the
dirtiest of the dirty work: openly spread the Birther lies.
Staffers in Hillary’s actual campaign used email to
spread the lies among other Democrats (this was a Democrat primary after all —
so that is the only well you needed to poison a month before a primary).
The campaign released the turban photo.
Hillary herself used 60 Minutes to further stoke
the story.
Ironically, during a February CNN Democratic town
hall in Columbia, South Carolina, Sanders referenced the Democrat-originated
“birther” movement. He suggested there was racism inherent in the Republican
base. “Nobody has asked for my birth certificate,” he said. “Maybe it’s the
color of my skin.”
They
had connived the false pneumonia story concerning Hillary's 9-11 physical and
mental breakdown and the media was pushing the story.
Bill
had cornered Loretta Lynch DOJ at the Arizona airport and convinced her to make
sure no indictment came down against Hillary concerning her private and not so
secret computer email server containing the nations secrets. Loretta would muzzle FBI James Comey at least
until after the elections but Hillary still had big bad fires out there.
The
Clinton Foundation scandal could explode any minute and the fancy law firms and
even Congress were applying some intense heat and Hillary's lead in the Poll
Numbers were shriveling.
Hillary
knew that Donald Trump was winning the race for the White House so she needed a
really big fire break or at least a lot of smoke.
Hillary
and her criminal crew decided to start up the BIRTHER conflict again; where was
Barack Obama really born, was he American or not?
With
a Birther smoke screen Hillary might be able to side swipe all her own scandals
giving the main stream media what they wanted, a scandal against Donald Trump.
Hillary
Clinton is losing and she must create that blanket of smoke to hide behind so
she can hide her secrets and stay away from crowded news conferences.
Hillary
knew she just about collapsed and died on 9-11 so desperately she wants to spar
with Trump but not close up blow by blow during the debates.
She
felt like she had been plunged into steaming water on 9-11 and she had seized
up and collapsed and damage had been done.
Hillary
Clinton now has a disastrous campaign and she's been trapped by her own lies
and history.
She
disappeared for a few days but now she was back in the game and it was her
move. Needless to say she needed a big
move to break out from Donald Trump again.
No comments:
Post a Comment